Search our site…

Pin It First - To Win It! | $5,000 Grand Prize

$5,000 Grand Prize! Cooperstown Pin Trade at the Fly Creek Cider Mill

Whether you're playing at the Cooperstown's All-Star Village or Cooperstown Dreams Park, it's all about the pin trading! 

Be the FIRST representative from your team to visit the Mill and Trade your Team's Pin and you'll receive our Pin and a FREE Sweet Cider Slush!

Collecting your Pin is Easy!

  1. Visit the Mill Store Check-out room.
  2. Tell us your team name.
  3. Be the FIRST player from your Team and you'll recieve a Pin.
  4. Register for the $5,000 Grand Prize and your TEAM could be a winner.

2022 Weekly winners who proceeded to $5000 Grand Prize Drawing:

  • Week One Winner -   Henderson Crawdads Black - Derek Wenzel - Pinned it First for his team while at the Cooperstown Dreams Park!
  • Week Two Winner - Utah Hustle - Jordan Tucker - Pinned it First for his team while at the Cooperstown Dreams Park!
  • Week Three Winner - Brandon Blazers - Gavin Mathis - Pinned it First for his team while at the Cooperstown Dreams Park!
  • Week Four Winner - Hilton Head Hurricanes - AJ Petro  - Pinned it First for his team while at the Cooperstown Dreams Park!
  • Week Five Winner  - THZ Futures - Joaquin Gathan - Pinned it First for his team while at Cooperstown All-Star Village!
  • Week Six Winner -
  • Week Seven Winner -
  • Week Eight Winner -
  • Week Nine Winner -
  • Week Ten Winner -
  • Week Eleven Winner -
  • Week Twelve Winner -
  • Week Thirteen Winner -
  • Week Fourteen Winner -
  • Week Fifteen Winner -
  • Week 16 Winner -

Grand Prize Contest Rules

2019 GRAND PRIZE DRAWING WINNER! - Week Eleven Winner - Aaron Hofbauer - Bethel Church League (no contest 2020 or 2021)

What our visitors are saying

“My son was very excited when he was the first on the board to trade pins for week 9. Your pin was the first one that he put in his pin book. He actually also traded pins with another boy in your Mill too. My family absolutely loved our visit to Fly Creek Cider Mill. We may even stop back by later in the week because we had such a great time. All of your staff were extremely welcoming and informative. Thank you for making our trip to Cooperstown and Fly Creek an amazing experience.”

-Alisha Bennett - Dreams Park Mom - Summer 2019

“I love coming to your store each time I am in Cooperstown. I have been bringing a team to play at the Dreams Park for over 15 years. My eldest son won it the second year the park was open. My youngest son also played at the park, he is now 27 yrs old. Each year I bring a new team and this Never gets old. Fly Creek Cider Mill is one of our Must go too! I tell my parents it's loveliest place for both adults and kids.”

-Liesel Campbell

“We were looking for a place to bring the team for a late lunch and were pleasantly surprised!  We called ahead for our party of 50 and they were ready for us.  Quick service, quality product (Pot Roast Sandwich and homemade Mac & Cheese the best) and a place for the adults to gather while the kids raced thier ducks - what could be better!”

-Dreams Park Team from Georgia 2018

“I am from California and recently visited your establishment. I cannot give you enough praise for the awesome experience, cordial employees and all-around beauty of your operation both inside and out. I just made some of your muffins from the mix I purchased-delicious.”

-Chrissie Annotti

“My wife and I had so much fun.  We couldn't wait to get home and tell our friends.  We are definitely coming back for more.”

-Gil Oliveras, Utica NY

“As I have. for the past 31 years, stopped by the store on Memorial Day weekend, I would just like to say how helpful your staff is!!!!!  Love the products, love the staff, you guys are the best!! Thrilled I can now, and have, order year round On-Line.”

-Dan Panarella, Staten Island NY

“Anyone that is looking for an interesting place to visit...this is it.  We also had lunch at your restaurant and bakery and it was awesome.  We are sure to back again.”

-Sharon McCoy, Hannibal NY

“This place is awesome. There's no better place! Their samples are awesome.”

-Tripadvisor.com member, Pittsburgh, PA
Website Development by