Search our site…

News

21
May
2026

Fly Creek Cider Mill’s Extra-Sharp, Mill-Aged New York State Cheddar – The Story

The tradition of cheese at the Fly Creek Cider Mill started long before present-day founder Charlie Michaels ordered his first wheel.    

The Michaels Family were long-time Main Street Merchants in near-by Cooperstown.  Starting around 1865 Nehemiah Michaels established the Washington Market purchasing the old Otsego County Sheriff Office and moving it to a vacant lot at 95 Main Street.  The store...

30
Nov
2025

November 30 -    Winner Announced

Flavorful Rewards Members, Debbie Wolf  is the winner of the Guess-The-Weight for the Giant Pumpkin.

Debbie Wolf and Betsy Stickle both guessed the correct weight of 909 pounds.   As per the contest rules both names were put into a drawing and Debbie' Ballot was chosen at random.

Congratulations Debbie and thank you to the more than 4,000 Flavorful Rewards Members who submitted a ballot.

...

5
Nov
2025

Call or e-mail us today to pre-order your Holiday Pies

Pies Available: Apple ($18.99), Apple Caramel ($19.99), Fruit of the Farm (blend of Apple, Raspberries, Blackberries, Strawberries and Rhubarb)( $22.99), Strawberry Rhubarb ($22.99), Blueberry ($24.99), Pumpkin ($18.99) & Pecan ($22.99).

To order call: 607-547-9692 and press zero or E-mail: info@flycreekcidermill.com.  Let us know the pick-up day.

Pick up November...

26
Aug
2023

Trifecta of Family Fun in Fly Creek on August 26: Unveiling a Day Packed with Entertainment and Community Spirit

FLY CREEK, NY – Get ready for a day brimming with excitement and camaraderie as three spectacular events converge in the heart of Fly Creek on Saturday, August 26. The synergy of Family Farm Day, Area-Wide Yard Sales, and the Antique Engine Show promises a memorable experience for all.

Family Farm Day: Delve into the world of agriculture as Otsego, Schoharie, and...

13
Aug
2023

The Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard emerged as the shining star of the Mohawk Valley, being honored with the prestigious Best Tourism/Season Attraction award at the recent Best of the Mohawk Valley Community's Choice Awards Gala. This remarkable achievement was celebrated in style on Wednesday night at Hart's Hill Inn, where the Mill's commitment to excellence and its dedication to creating unforgettable experiences for visitors were acknowledged and celebrated.

Sponsored by the...




Pages

Website Development by