Search our site…

*** Winter Sale! ***

Today 25% off many categories. Open daily 10 - 5:30. Closing January 31
Mill Store - Open Everyday 10:00 - 5:30 - NO PHONE ORDERS, HOLDS or LAY-AWAYS.

To Our Loyal Customers:
We regretfully announce that the Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard will be closing on Sunday, January 31, 2021.
During the next two weeks, our remaining inventory will be highly discounted and we encourage everyone to stock up on their favorite flavors of the Mill.  This inventory reduction sale applies to Mill Store purchases only and excludes all E-Commerce sales.
As the recovery from the pandemic progresses we will re-assess our position.
We appreciate all of your support over the years. Thank you for your patience during this difficult time and please stay safe.
Sincerely,
The Michaels Family

Featured Products

Apple Butter

Habanero Garlic Pickled

1856 Bouillabaisse

Apple Butter Syrup & Topping

Fly Creek Cookbook

What our visitors are saying

“I've had the wonderful opportunity to try several of your goodies.  I work at a Vet Clinic in the Southern Tier and clients have given us your products as thank you gifts for caring for thier pets.  Amazing products and I have told myself I WILL get there soon - can't wait!”

-Susan Green - Endwell, New York

“I love coming to your store each time I am in Cooperstown. I have been bringing a team to play at the Dreams Park for over 15 years. My eldest son won it the second year the park was open. My youngest son also played at the park, he is now 27 yrs old. Each year I bring a new team and this Never gets old. Fly Creek Cider Mill is one of our Must go too! I tell my parents it's loveliest place for both adults and kids.”

-Liesel Campbell

“This is one of my new favorite places on earth. Came to Cooperstown for the Baseball HOF festivities, might stay here JUST for this place... and I love baseball. FIVE STARS.”

-Michael Cook - FaceBook

“"You are one of the BEST companies to visit or call and order from.  Your staff is always helpful, kind and courteous.  Thank you!"”

-Concetta S.

“The Mill is a cook's or foodie's dream and the assortment of products couldn't be any more impressive. I love following the arrows as we made our way through each section of treats all beautifully displayed. There were new samples and aromas at every turn! Our weekend in Cooperstown was incredible and the Mill was the perfect stop.”

-Marci - Cooperstown Visitor

“We were looking for a place to bring the team for a late lunch and were pleasantly surprised!  We called ahead for our party of 50 and they were ready for us.  Quick service, quality product (Pot Roast Sandwich and homemade Mac & Cheese the best) and a place for the adults to gather while the kids raced thier ducks - what could be better!”

-Dreams Park Team from Georgia 2018

“Happy Bastion of Everything Apple”

-Backroads Magazine - Feburary 18

“I am from California and recently visited your establishment. I cannot give you enough praise for the awesome experience, cordial employees and all-around beauty of your operation both inside and out. I just made some of your muffins from the mix I purchased-delicious.”

-Chrissie Annotti

“The Cider is the Best Ever and the Apples are the size of Grapefruits!”

-TripAdvisor Reviewer

“Your's is probably some of the best fudge I've ever had.  It was so smooth and creamy!! The chocolate satisified the need for chocolate. ”

-Rebecca Dean, Norwich NY

“The Mill is a jewel of the area!”

-Howard Smith, Cherry Valley, NY

“Your place was lovely. During our stay we visited your facility at lease six times! Everyone raved about your products. My husband loved the pot roast sandwich.”

-Danielle Sykes, Dreams Park Mom
Website Development by